Charcoal vs. Gas Grills: Which One Should You Get?

June 3, 2022

Summer is almost here, and you’re probably looking forward to hosting pool or garden parties. For exceptional gatherings outdoors, a barbecue grill is a must-have. As people say, “No backyard is complete without a BBQ grill.” So, if you still don’t have one, now is the best time to get one!

The question is, which type of grill should you get? Many of us must have heard about the charcoal vs. gas grills debate. It is a long-standing argument about which is better. The truth is, your choice will depend on your priorities and preferences.

There are different factors to consider when choosing the right grill. Each type has its advantages and trade-offs. We listed them down to help you decide.

Upfront Cost

If you don’t want to shell out a sizeable amount initially, you can go for charcoal grills. Many of them cost only about the same as a decent pair of shoes, or maybe even less. Their simplicity logically translates to affordable prices.

With gas grills, you’re talking about a few hundred dollars (except for those portable ones used for camping). If you believe you will have barbecues often, though, high-end units can be worth the investment.

Ease of Use

Gas grills shine in this aspect. For most units of this type, you only need to hold the igniter button and turn on the burn control knob to start them, making the start and heat-up time faster than charcoal-fed ones. You can also easily control the heat via the control knob. 

Food Taste

If you prefer that classic, smoky taste, charcoal is the way to go. The secret is in the high heat that charcoal produces. The drippings from meat or vegetables also fall on the coals, which are then brought back up in the form of aromatic steam that coats the food.


With charcoal, there’s ash and leftover coals to deal with after cooking — things that are non-existent with gas grills. Just make sure to empty the grease collection tray as needed.

Long-Term Fuel Costs

While a bag of charcoal can be inexpensive, you’ll burn through it within a handful of parties. A tank of propane gas may cost more upfront, but it can also last for a couple of dozen of BBQ sessions.

Size and Storage

Charcoal grills are typically smaller than their gas-powered counterparts. Some models are also small enough to be carried with you on camping trips.

There are no hard and fast rules as to which type of grill is the best. Pick the one that you deem will best serve your needs. If you’re still unsure about the whole “charcoal vs. gas grills” thing, visit us at Eagan Hardware Hank in Eagan, MN. Our friendly representatives can guide you through our selection of outdoor grills and help you choose the right one for you.